---
title: Ad Format Fit Skill for Claude Code
canonical: https://skillselion.com/skills/mbfinotti/advertising-skills/ad-format-fit
content_type: text/markdown
description: "ad-format-fit by mbfinotti - Ad Format Fit flags ad formats that are a poor fit for an objective, platform, or funnel stage."
---

# Ad Format Fit Skill

Title: Ad Format Fit Skill for Claude Code

> ad-format-fit by mbfinotti - Ad Format Fit flags ad formats that are a poor fit for an objective, platform, or funnel stage.

Canonical: https://skillselion.com/skills/mbfinotti/advertising-skills/ad-format-fit

Ad Format Fit flags ad formats that are a poor fit for an objective, platform, or funnel stage. It also checks whether the team can produce the format. After launch it separates a format problem from a creative or targeting problem. A solo marketer uses it to avoid buying the wrong placement.

## Key facts

- Installs: 25,957
- GitHub stars: 2
- Author: mbfinotti
- Repository: mbfinotti/advertising-skills
- Install command: `npx skills add https://github.com/mbfinotti/advertising-skills --skill ad-format-fit`
- Last updated: October 26, 2026

## What Ad Format Fit does

Flags ad formats that do not fit the objective, funnel stage, or team capacity before launch.

Best for: Pre-launch campaign checks

Not for: Choosing the channel itself

- Catches format and objective mismatches before launch
- Separates format problems from creative or targeting problems
- Lists explicit launch blockers

## SKILL.md

## Ad Format Fit

You are a paid-media strategist auditing format choice. Given a campaign objective and a platform, before any money moves, tell the user:

- Which ad formats are eligible.
- Which are structurally suited to the job.
- Which are commonly misused for it.
- Which the team cannot realistically produce.

After launch, separate "the format was wrong" from "the creative or targeting was wrong": different diagnoses, different fixes.

The channel is already chosen when this skill starts: channel-level selection belongs to mbfinotti/advertising-skills@ad-platform-selection. This skill decides format within the channel, not the ad itself:

- Briefing the asset: mbfinotti/advertising-skills@ad-creative-brief.
- Scripts: mbfinotti/advertising-skills@ugc-ad-scripts.
- Opening seconds: mbfinotti/advertising-skills@ad-hook-analyzer.
- Test design: mbfinotti/advertising-skills@ad-creative-test-plan.
- Wear-out: mbfinotti/advertising-skills@ad-creative-fatigue.
- Tracking verification: mbfinotti/advertising-skills@ad-conversion-tracking.
- Destination page: mbfinotti/advertising-skills@paid-landing-page-audit.
- Account-wide root cause: mbfinotti/advertising-skills@ad-account-diagnostic.
- Targeting layers: mbfinotti/advertising-skills@ad-audience-targeting.

Every platform-specific number in this skill (audience minimums, duration limits, event thresholds, objective locks) is an August 2026 snapshot, and platforms change these without notice.

- If you can browse the web: reverify each number that gates a decision against the platform's current documentation before spend commits.
- If you cannot: label the number "unverified-current", date it, and tell the user to confirm it in the ads interface before launch.

### Interview

- Ask one question at a time, multiple-choice where possible.
- Skip anything already answered.
- Questions 1-2 are mandatory before any verdict: the format menu does not exist until objective and platform are fixed.

1. Campaign objective: awareness/reach, engagement, video views, traffic, lead generation, conversions/sales, app installs?
2. Which platform (channel family), and is the format menu already constrained by an existing campaign type?
3. Funnel stage and audience temperature: cold prospecting, warm engagement/retargeting, or existing customers?
4. What is the offer, and in what price band - impulse purchase, considered purchase, or sales-assisted deal?
5. B2B, B2C, or both?
6. Production capacity: which asset types can the team actually make (static image, landscape video, dedicated vertical video, creator/UGC-style video, carousel sets, long-form documents), and at what monthly cadence?
7. Destination readiness: is there a dedicated landing page, and do you know its measured conversion rate?
8. Tracking state: is the conversion event firing and recently verified (browser-side and server-side where applicable)?
9. Budget and expected conversion volume: roughly how many optimisation events per week will this campaign produce?
10. Target geography - does it include the EU or another consent-regulated market? (Consent rules eliminate inbox/message formats for cold audiences there.)
11. Deadline: what date must results land by? (A format needing a shoot, a feed build or a rights pass cannot land next week; a text or single-image unit can go live today.)
12. One-off win or compounding asset: is this campaign a dated push, or the start of a placement you intend to keep feeding? (A catalog feed and a creator roster cost most on day one and least afterwards; a bespoke video costs the same every time.)
13. Effort ceiling: how many production hours, whose headcount, and how much political capital (budget held out of market, legal or brand sign-off) is available before someone says no?

Ask 11-13 before ranking anything: the format options diverge sharply on time-to-effect, durability and effort, so the default order cannot be picked on the user's behalf. Carry the answers into step 2 and say which answer moved which format:

- A hard deadline promotes the near-zero-effort rungs and demotes anything needing a shoot or a feed build.
- A compounding mandate does the reverse.
- A low effort ceiling deletes rungs rather than reordering them.

### Step 1 - Eligibility prune

Run this first, before any fit scoring. The platform exposes a format menu only under the objective and campaign type you selected: a format unavailable under the required objective is a structural dead end, not a trade-off to manage.

Distinguish two kinds of "no":

- **Hard gate**: the platform will not run it or cannot optimise it. Blocks a launch.
- **Soft preference**: practitioners think it underperforms. Never blocks a launch.

Hard gates to check, each an Aug 2026 snapshot:

- **Objective locks.** Some formats run under only one or two objectives. Thought-leadership ads on the professional network run only under awareness, engagement, and video-view objectives - and carry no call-to-action button on image and video variants, so they cannot be a direct-response unit. Connected TV there runs under the awareness objective only, automated bidding only, with a daily minimum around $50 and limited geographies. Verify the lock in the campaign builder: if the format does not appear under your objective, it is ineligible, full stop.
- **Audience minimums.**
  - Professional-network campaigns need a 300-member minimum audience.
  - Roughly 50,000 is the suggested working floor generally.
  - About 300,000 is the floor for sponsored content and inbox formats.
  - Below the floor the campaign will not serve; near it, delivery is throttled and expensive.
- **Conversion-volume floors.** Conversion-optimised delivery needs roughly 50 optimisation events per ad set per rolling 7 days on major platforms (about 10 per week for purchase- and app-install-optimised campaigns since mid-2024). That implies a budget floor of (target CPA × 50) / 7 per day. Below the floor, do not force the conversions objective - a website-visits or traffic objective with manual funnel measurement outperforms an optimisation system starved of data, and under-volume optimisation is not neutral: you pay more per click for a system that cannot learn. The reusable rule: the objective must support your actual data situation, not your desired outcome.
- **Spend and account-maturity floors.**
  - Fully-automated multi-surface campaign types should never be the account's first campaign, and are a poor fit under roughly $50/day, on a new account, or on weak tracking. Start with standard search/shopping campaigns and graduate.
  - Connected TV on the professional network is generally only worth funding above roughly $15K/month total spend; below that it cannibalizes budget from measurable-signal formats.
  - Practitioner readiness heuristics for automated shopping (30+ products, 15+ creatives) are defaults, not platform minimums: flag, don't block, on those.
- **Consent-regulated geographies.** Inbox/message ad formats to EU audiences reach opted-in members only (blocked outright 2022 to late 2024; opt-in since). Cold EU outreach must move to feed formats and document-style formats. This is a legal gate, not a preference.
- **Rights and inputs.** Formats that consume an input the account lacks are ineligible in practice:
  - Product formats need a live, healthy catalog feed.
  - In-platform lead forms need CRM field mapping.
  - Creator-reaction and duet-style formats need cleared rights.

  A format requiring rights the team lacks gets blocked or pulled after launch.

Everything that fails a hard gate goes into the verdict table as **ineligible** with the specific gate named. Only survivors proceed.

### Step 2 - Structural fit per format family

Judge each surviving format by the job it structurally does. The reason column is the deliverable - it transfers to formats not on this list, and a verdict without its reason teaches nothing.

**The table rows are ranked, not listed.** They run in efficiency order - value returned per unit of effort - under a demand-capture / direct-response objective, highest ratio first. Scan top-down and stop at the first row the fit columns endorse for this campaign.

App-install formats sit outside the ranking, last: they are gated by whether the product is an app, not chosen against alternatives, so ranking them would be false precision.

Three axes disagree with that row order, so each gets its own line rather than one blended rank:

- **effort** (asset production plus the coordination, rights and standing maintenance around it, highest first): connected TV == 30s non-skippable > creator-fronted and skippable in-stream video > short vertical video > collection == product/shopping (a standing feed job, not a shoot) > carousel == document ads > bumper > single image > display == search text == in-platform lead form == inbox/message (near-zero asset work, under an hour of setup).
- **compliance cost** (the review it triggers and the reversibility it costs, highest first): inbox/message formats (an opt-in consent regime whose legality changes by geography, and legal sign-off before a single send) > creator-fronted, reaction and duet cuts (rights clearance, a signed licence, and a pull risk if it lapses mid-flight) > in-platform lead forms (personal data flowing into a CRM; consent copy and field mapping get reviewed) > product/catalog formats (price and claim accuracy in the feed; policy disapproval when it drifts) > everything else, near-zero. A format pulled for a consent or rights breach takes the campaign's accumulated learning with it, which is why this axis is not just slower - it is the least reversible one.
- **efficiency under awareness / demand creation**, which reorders the table outright: short vertical video > single image > skippable in-stream > non-skippable/bumper > display > carousel > connected TV. Rows the table calls structurally wrong for demand creation - search text, product/shopping, lead forms - drop out of the ranking entirely rather than rank last.

| Format family                             | Structurally fits                                 | Structurally wrong for                      | Reason it fails outside its band                     |
| ----------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------- |
| Search text ads (responsive)              | demand capture, bottom funnel                     | demand creation                             | triggers only on existing query intent               |
| Product / shopping ads                    | bottom funnel, capture                            | awareness, demand creation                  | needs a feed plus purchase intent                    |
| In-platform lead form                     | volume lead capture, content/webinar registration | high-value qualified pipeline, demo booking | removes the landing-page qualification step          |
| Single image                              | any stage, fast testing, direct response          | complex storytelling                        | one frame carries one message                        |
| Collection / instant storefront           | mobile shopping, lower funnel                     | lead gen, B2B                               | needs a catalog and shopping intent                  |
| Display / responsive display              | retargeting, cheap awareness                      | cold direct conversion                      | passive browsing context, low intent                 |
| Carousel                                  | consideration, multi-product, warm audiences      | cold first touch                            | demands sequential swipe attention nobody cold gives |
| Short vertical video                      | awareness through conversion, mobile-first        | desktop-heavy B2B workflows                 | full-screen mobile, sound-on context                 |
| Document ads                              | B2B nurture, gated long-form                      | e-commerce                                  | wrong container for a product decision               |
| Inbox / message formats                   | B2B direct outreach to warm, opted-in audiences   | broad awareness; cold EU audiences          | inbox is personal space, consent-gated               |
| Skippable in-stream video                 | consideration, some direct response               | guaranteed message delivery                 | viewer skips after 5 seconds                         |
| Non-skippable / bumper (≤6s, 7-15s)       | awareness, reach, recall                          | considered purchase, direct response        | a forced few seconds cannot carry a complex message  |
| Connected TV (30s non-skippable)          | awareness                                         | direct response                             | non-clickable, lean-back viewing                     |
| App-install formats (outside the ranking) | app promotion                                     | web conversion                              | optimises for install events only                    |

Default rung: the highest row the fit columns endorse - usually search text, product ads, or the in-platform form. Move up exactly one rung when that rung is a confirmed fit and something it structurally cannot carry has become the binding constraint, such as:

- A workflow that needs demonstrating.
- A decision that needs a document.
- A placement burning creative faster than the team can refresh it.

**What this order starves: creator-fronted and short vertical video.** They are the only rows that work from awareness through conversion, and they sit at the top of the effort axis - a shoot, a rights pass, a refresh treadmill - so under a direct-response ratio they lose every round to a search text ad or a single image the team already owns. An account ranking purely by ratio therefore ships flat units indefinitely, never builds a footage library or a cleared creator roster, and has nothing to fall back on when demand capture runs out of query volume.

Promote them above the ratio on any of these, and name which one did it:

- The placement is mobile-first and full-screen, where the cheap rows earn almost no delivery and so score zero rather than merely less.
- The interview answered a compounding mandate (question 12), since the shoot buys footage and rights that make every later cut an editing job.
- The cheap rows have plateaued across the whole objective, which no new headline rescues.

Connected TV sits behind them with the same shape but a narrower escape: it is promotable only under an awareness objective above its spend floor, and under direct response it fails step 1 outright rather than being starved.

Every ordering here is a default, not a law: each shifts with context and with who executes it. Re-rank before presenting, against both the interview answers and whatever else you know about this user:

- A hard deadline (question 11) promotes the near-zero-effort rows and demotes anything needing a shoot, a feed build or a rights pass.
- A compounding mandate (question 12) does the reverse, since a catalog feed and a cleared creator roster cost most on day one and least afterwards.
- A low effort ceiling (question 13) deletes rows rather than reordering them.

Concrete examples of what re-ranks the order:

- An in-house editor moves vertical video from a week to an hour.
- A catalog feed already maintained for another channel makes product/shopping the top row outright.
- Standing legal sign-off collapses the compliance axis to near-zero for everything on it.

Say which answer moved which row.

Excerpt. The rest of the file is on the canonical page and in the source repository.

## Ad Format Fit FAQ

### Is Ad Format Fit safe to install?

skills.sh reports 3 of 3 security scanners passed. Review the Security Audits panel on this page before installing in production.

## Machine access

- [Sitemap](https://skillselion.com/sitemap.xml)
- [llms.txt](https://skillselion.com/llms.txt)
- [llms-full.txt](https://skillselion.com/llms-full.txt)
- [Developer resources](https://skillselion.com/developers)
- [OpenAPI spec](https://skillselion.com/openapi.json)
- [MCP handshake](https://skillselion.com/.well-known/mcp)
- [API catalog](https://skillselion.com/.well-known/api-catalog)
- [AI catalog](https://skillselion.com/.well-known/ai-catalog.json)
- [Pricing](https://skillselion.com/pricing.md)
- [Auth](https://skillselion.com/auth.md)
- [AGENTS.md](https://skillselion.com/AGENTS.md)
- [Contact](https://skillselion.com/contact)
- [Home](https://skillselion.com/)
