---
title: Ad Platform Selection Skill for Claude Code
canonical: https://skillselion.com/skills/mbfinotti/advertising-skills/ad-platform-selection
content_type: text/markdown
description: "ad-platform-selection by mbfinotti - This skill decides which paid channel families fit a business's economics, audience, funnel stage and budget at campaign."
---

# Ad Platform Selection Skill

Title: Ad Platform Selection Skill for Claude Code

> ad-platform-selection by mbfinotti - This skill decides which paid channel families fit a business's economics, audience, funnel stage and budget at campaign.

Canonical: https://skillselion.com/skills/mbfinotti/advertising-skills/ad-platform-selection

This skill decides which paid channel families fit a business's economics, audience, funnel stage and budget at campaign setup. It compares paid search, paid social, short-form video, connected TV, native, retail media, programmatic, audio and B2B networks, including whether each is affordable against allowable CAC. A solo founder reaches for it before choosing where to spend their first paid budget.

## Key facts

- Installs: 26,674
- GitHub stars: 2
- Author: mbfinotti
- Repository: mbfinotti/advertising-skills
- Install command: `npx skills add https://github.com/mbfinotti/advertising-skills --skill ad-platform-selection`
- Last updated: October 26, 2026

## What Ad Platform Selection does

Decides which paid channels fit a business's economics, audience and budget, such as search, social, video or connected TV.

Channels are chosen by habit and not by economics.

A shortlist of affordable channels for the budget.

Best for: Founders picking their first paid channels.

Not for: Businesses that already run a stable channel mix.

- Compares search, social, video, CTV, native and B2B networks
- Checks affordability against allowable CAC
- Fits channel to funnel stage and budget

## SKILL.md

## Platform Selection

You are a paid-media strategist. Recommend which paid channel family (or small set of families) a business should run, given its unit economics, audience, funnel stage, and budget. This is a one-time, campaign-setup decision framework: it ends with a channel plan naming one funded primary channel, the reasons every other channel was rejected, and a test with pass/fail criteria.

Channel choice is arithmetic, not preference. Work in channel categories, never in one vendor's product vocabulary - every family here has several competing vendors that share the same mechanics.

What decides the shortlist:

- Economics decide what is affordable.
- Learning thresholds decide what can produce a readable signal.
- Regulation, geography, and operational capacity eliminate the rest.

Out of scope - hand off to the sibling skill instead of covering it here:

- Recurring budget split across running channels: mbfinotti/advertising-skills@ad-spend-allocation
- Day-to-day pacing: mbfinotti/advertising-skills@ad-budget-pacing
- Bidding method: mbfinotti/advertising-skills@ad-bidding-strategy
- Setting the CAC ceiling / ROAS floor policy: mbfinotti/advertising-skills@ad-spend-guardrails
- Benchmarking current CAC/ROAS health: mbfinotti/advertising-skills@cac-roas-benchmark
- Scaling a proven channel: mbfinotti/advertising-skills@paid-media-scaling
- Audience tiering: mbfinotti/advertising-skills@ad-audience-targeting
- Ad format choice: mbfinotti/advertising-skills@ad-format-fit
- Creative variant tests: mbfinotti/advertising-skills@ad-creative-test-plan
- Tracking verification: mbfinotti/advertising-skills@ad-conversion-tracking
- Landing page review: mbfinotti/advertising-skills@paid-landing-page-audit

This skill uses allowable CAC and payback as gates: it takes those targets as input, rather than setting them.

A note on every number in this skill and its references: the largest public benchmark datasets are published by vendors with a commercial interest in more ad spend, and their medians hide very wide variance (published search CPCs in one vertical span roughly $1.50 to $50+). Treat all figures as directional ranges, never as targets. If you can browse the web, reverify any figure against current platform documentation before spend commits; if you cannot, say the figure is unverified-current and date it.

### Interview

Ask one question at a time, multiple-choice where possible. Skip anything already answered. Do not recommend anything until the economics questions (2-6) are answered or explicitly unknown.

1. B2B, B2C, or both?
2. What do you sell, and at what price - average order value (B2C) or annual contract value (B2B)?
3. Gross margin: under 30% / 30-50% / 50-70% / over 70%?
4. LTV and retention, if known. (Unknown is fine - the gate falls back to first-order contribution.)
5. Sales cycle: impulse (hours-days) / weeks / about a quarter / multi-quarter?
6. Total monthly budget available for paid media?
7. Target geographies and languages?
8. Is the category regulated or restricted anywhere you sell (credit, employment, housing, financial products, health, alcohol, gambling, crypto, weapons, adult, political/advocacy)?
9. Who is the buyer, and where do they already concentrate - what do they search, watch, listen to, or scroll?
10. Which paid channels are already running, and with what results?
11. Creative production capacity: how many net-new assets per month, and video or static only?
12. Are landing pages and conversion tracking live and verified?
13. If lead-gen: how fast does sales follow up on a new lead?
14. Which channel families does the team already know how to run?
15. By what date must results have landed - a specific date, not "soon"?
16. Do you want a one-off win this quarter, or a compounding asset that keeps returning?
17. What is your effort ceiling: assets per month, hours per week, headcount, and how reversible the commitment has to be?

Question 14 is a scoring input, not a shortcut - "the channel the team knows" is a named failure mode when it overrides the economics.

Questions 15-17 re-rank step 4's default ordering, so ask them before recommending anything.

- Q15 (near date): promotes the fast-acting capture rungs (paid search, retargeting, retail media); demotes every creation family whose verdict takes a quarter.
- Q16 (compounding mandate): promotes short-form video, podcast/audio and paid social prospecting, whose creative library and audience keep working after the flight ends.
- Q17 (tight effort ceiling): promotes low-burn families (paid search, retargeting, B2B professional networks at ~4-6 weeks per asset); rules out the standing creative jobs outright, whatever they score on value.

### Step 1 - Affordability gate

Run this before looking at any channel. It is identical for B2B and B2C; only the input names change (AOV vs. ACV, ROAS vs. pipeline).

1. Contribution margin per sale = price × gross margin rate (net of variable costs).
2. Break-even ROAS = 1 / contribution margin rate. A 60% margin breaks even at ~1.67x; the folk target of "4x ROAS" is wrong for most businesses. For reference, the median paid-social ROAS across a ~35,000-brand ecommerce benchmark dataset was 1.86-1.93x - profitable only above roughly a 50% margin.
3. Allowable CAC = the maximum contribution you will spend to acquire a customer. If the org has set one (mbfinotti/advertising-skills@ad-spend-guardrails), take it as given; otherwise derive it from the payback target below.
4. Payback period = CAC / monthly gross profit per customer. Target band: 3-12 months; up to 18 months for enterprise sales motions. Under 3 months usually signals underinvestment, not health.
5. Discounted payback = CAC / (monthly gross profit × annual retention rate). Worked check: $300 CAC, $99/month gross profit, 70% retention → 3.0 months raw but 4.3 months discounted. When retention is weak, discounted payback blows past 12 months even when raw payback looks fine - that gap is the early warning.
6. Delete every channel family whose realistic benchmark CPA/CPL exceeds allowable CAC (directional ranges: [references/channel-family-profiles.md](references/channel-family-profiles.md)). Deleted means gone from the candidate set for this account and named in the plan's deleted list with the gate it failed - never carried into step 4's table as a low-scoring row. A ruled-out family left at the bottom of a score table reappears as scope for whoever reads the table without the gate.

Compute payback per plan or per cohort, never on blended averages. The same $300 CAC is ~33 months on a $9/month plan (unaffordable - route that tier to organic or product-led motions), 3.0 months at $99/month, and days at $999/month. One blended number describes none of them.

Worked gate: an $80-AOV product at 40% margin leaves ~$32 contribution - that excludes B2B professional networks (CPLs commonly $100+) and most connected TV before any scoring happens. A B2B product near the ~$32,000 average B2B SaaS LTV can absorb both.

#### Why payback is the gate, not LTV:CAC

The popular 3:1 LTV:CAC test has four flaws:

1. It assumes every customer churns - the best customers compound instead.
2. It assumes churn is evenly timed - in practice most churn front-loads into the first three months.
3. Blended ARPU hides per-plan variance - a $9/month and a $999/month plan average into a number that describes neither.
4. It ignores revenue delay - free trials and long sales cycles mean cash arrives after CAC is spent, and that gap is where companies run out of cash.

Use LTV:CAC only as a secondary sanity check, and only when payback is already under 12 months.

### Step 2 - Disqualifier pass

Delete channels the business cannot legally, geographically, or operationally run, including any target market where the family has no inventory. A deleted channel leaves the candidate set entirely and is named in the plan's deleted list with its reason; it never appears in step 4's table, whatever it would have scored. Full checklist with sourced specifics: [references/disqualifier-checklist.md](references/disqualifier-checklist.md).

- **Regulated category rules**: credit, employment, housing, and financial-product offers trigger restricted-targeting regimes on major social platforms (demographic and geographic narrowing stripped, similar-audience tools removed); other restricted categories (alcohol, gambling, crypto, health, weapons, adult) face outright bans, certification requirements, or geo-limits per channel.
- **Political and issue ads**: the largest search and social platforms exited EU political, electoral, and social-issue advertising entirely in October 2025 under the TTPA - for that messaging in the EU, those families simply do not exist.
- **Geography and language**: several major markets block the global search/social platforms or are dominated by local ones (search, social, and messaging each have local leaders in China, South Korea, Japan, Russia, Vietnam, and others); connected TV and retail media are heavily US-concentrated.
- **Channel maturity by market**: a family that is mainstream in one market can be marginal in the target market - check before scoring, not after launch.
- **Capacity gates**:
  - Creative production volume: short-form video and paid social burn creative faster than most teams can produce it.
  - Landing pages: cold-traffic channels waste their entire learning phase without dedicated, tested pages.
  - Speed-to-lead: slow sales follow-up collapses lead-gen conversion and makes the channel look unprofitable when the constraint is operational.

### Step 3 - Demand state and funnel stage

Classify what the budget must do. This distinction is identical for B2B and B2C.

- **Demand capture** harvests intent that already exists: paid search, retargeting, retail media, paid review listings. Fastest payback; ceiling limited by existing demand.
- **Demand creation** generates intent that doesn't exist yet: paid social, short-form video, connected TV, podcast/audio, native/discovery. Slower payback; the only way to grow past the captured ceiling.

Decision logic: if the category has search volume and capture is underfunded, capture comes first - it returns the most per hour spent, because the intent already exists and the creative burden is a text ad plus a landing page. If nobody searches for the category, capture cannot be the primary and a creation channel must be, with the longer payback and the standing creative job priced in. Multi-quarter sales cycles eventually need both, but the sequencing still starts at the higher ratio, not the larger ceiling.

Warning that must precede any data read: platform-reported attribution systematically over-credits capture channels and undercounts creation channels - last-click favors the channels people pass through when already ready to buy; one practitioner analysis estimates social is under-reported by roughly 70%. A naive read of existing dashboards therefore biases the channel decision toward the bottom of the funnel before you have decided anything.

Named frameworks that fit this step when the user wants a fuller exploration:

- Bullseye method: brainstorm all channels, cheaply test 3-4, concentrate on the single best.
- Four Fits framework (channel-model fit): "lower ARPU models depend on lower CAC channels, while higher ARPU models can afford higher CAC channels" - products mold to channels, not the reverse.

### Step 4 - Rank the survivors by efficiency

Rank every family that survived steps 1-2 by value returned per unit of effort - never by whichever is cheapest to start. Cheap and efficient are different orderings, and only the second answers "which one first". Policy eligibility is already handled by the disqualifier pass and is not re-scored.

Effort here is what the team spends:

- Assets produced per month.
- Setup hours.
- Coordination with third parties.
- Skill already in-house.
- How reversible the commitment is.

Default ordering, before anything specific to this business is known:

- efficiency: paid search > retargeting > retail media > paid social prospecting > B2B professional networks > short-form video > podcast/audio > connected TV
- value (ceiling the family can reach): paid social prospecting > short-form video > paid search > connected TV > B2B professional networks > podcast/audio > retail media > retargeting
- effort: connected TV > podcast/audio > short-form video > paid social prospecting > B2B professional networks > retail media > paid search > retargeting
- time-to-effect: paid search (days from a cold start) > retargeting (days, but only once a traffic pool has accumulated) > retail media (weeks) > paid social prospecting (exits learning at ~50 events per ad set per 7 days) > B2B professional networks (a quarter of committed spend is the practitioner norm) > short-form video (serves the day assets land, but needs several fatigue cycles to read) > podcast/audio (show booking lead times delay the first impression) > connected TV (production, then an incrementality build, before any readable result)
- compliance cost: podcast/audio (host improvises the claim on air, so review covers wording you never see) > connected TV (booked flights, creative clearance, no clean way to pull back mid-flight) > retargeting (consent for audience lists, data-residency review) > paid social prospecting == B2B professional networks (special-ad-category declaration strips targeting for regulated offers) > short-form video (talent and music rights on creator-made assets, with usage windows that expire mid-flight) > retail media (marketplace listing terms) > paid search (ad-copy policy review only)

The one tie is real: paid social prospecting and B2B professional networks face the same self-declaration for the same four regulated categories, and both answer it by stripping targeting rather than by review - identical in kind, in cost, and in timing.

**What this order starves.** A ratio demotes whatever is high on value and high on effort, and here that is podcast/audio and connected TV: the highest monthly minimums and the longest wait for a readable verdict. Step 1's affordability gate and step 5's funding floor push the same two down a second and third time, so a plan built on efficiency alone never funds them, even when they are the only families that reach the buyer at all. Short-form video is the same failure one row up, and gets the same treatment when video production is already in-house.

Promote one to primary against its rank only when all four hold:

- Interview Q9 evidence puts the buyer on that surface.
- No capture family reaches them (thin category search volume, not sold on a host marketplace).
- The budget clears that family's floor by concentrating rather than spreading.
- The Q15 deadline sits at least a full quarter out.

Where the axes disagree: paid social prospecting and short-form video hold the highest value ceilings and the heaviest effort - a standing creative job, not a setup task - which is why they sit mid-table on efficiency while topping value. Retargeting is near-zero effort and tops nothing on value; it multiplies traffic already being bought and is never a primary.

Rows that move with business type:

- Professional networks usually leave at step 1 for consumer offers.
- Paid social prospecting rises to second behind paid search for broad consumer categories - the same call step 3 already makes on capture versus creation.

Native/discovery, programmatic display and paid review listings are deliberately left out of the ordering. Placing them against benchmarked families would be invented precision because cost and value vary too widely to rank. Treat them as a price-discovery bucket: eligible as a second channel once a tiny test returns a real number, never as the funded primary on a first plan.

Excerpt. The rest of the file is on the canonical page and in the source repository.

## Ad Platform Selection FAQ

### Is Ad Platform Selection safe to install?

skills.sh reports 3 of 3 security scanners passed. Review the Security Audits panel on this page before installing in production.

## Machine access

- [Sitemap](https://skillselion.com/sitemap.xml)
- [llms.txt](https://skillselion.com/llms.txt)
- [llms-full.txt](https://skillselion.com/llms-full.txt)
- [Developer resources](https://skillselion.com/developers)
- [OpenAPI spec](https://skillselion.com/openapi.json)
- [MCP handshake](https://skillselion.com/.well-known/mcp)
- [API catalog](https://skillselion.com/.well-known/api-catalog)
- [AI catalog](https://skillselion.com/.well-known/ai-catalog.json)
- [Pricing](https://skillselion.com/pricing.md)
- [Auth](https://skillselion.com/auth.md)
- [AGENTS.md](https://skillselion.com/AGENTS.md)
- [Contact](https://skillselion.com/contact)
- [Home](https://skillselion.com/)
