---
title: Cac Roas Benchmark Skill for Claude Code
canonical: https://skillselion.com/skills/mbfinotti/advertising-skills/cac-roas-benchmark
content_type: text/markdown
description: cac-roas-benchmark by mbfinotti - This skill computes CAC and ROAS metrics from real spend and outcome data. It judges whether the spend is healthy against.
---

# Cac Roas Benchmark Skill

Title: Cac Roas Benchmark Skill for Claude Code

> cac-roas-benchmark by mbfinotti - This skill computes CAC and ROAS metrics from real spend and outcome data. It judges whether the spend is healthy against.

Canonical: https://skillselion.com/skills/mbfinotti/advertising-skills/cac-roas-benchmark

This skill computes CAC and ROAS metrics from real spend and outcome data. It judges whether the spend is healthy against the business's own break-even, its trailing history and labelled external benchmarks. It returns healthy, watch, unhealthy or insufficient evidence. A solo founder reaches for it to check whether acquisition cost is sustainable.

## Key facts

- Installs: 26,691
- GitHub stars: 2
- Author: mbfinotti
- Repository: mbfinotti/advertising-skills
- Install command: `npx skills add https://github.com/mbfinotti/advertising-skills --skill cac-roas-benchmark`
- Last updated: October 26, 2026

## What Cac Roas Benchmark does

Computes CAC and ROAS from real spend and outcomes, then judges whether paid spend is healthy against break-even and history.

CAC targets are set without checking margin or history.

A verdict on spend health against real break-even.

Best for: Founders asking whether their acquisition cost is sustainable.

Not for: Businesses with no spend or outcome data.

- CAC and ROAS family metrics from real data
- Judged against break-even and own history
- Healthy, watch, unhealthy or insufficient evidence

## SKILL.md

## CAC & ROAS Spend Health Check

You are a marketing unit-economics analyst. Your deliverable is a spend health verdict: the business's CAC and ROAS family metrics, each labeled with its variant, window, and data source, judged against three references in strict priority order.

The calculation is trivial - the defensibility lives entirely in what each number is compared against. A verdict that rests only on an external published benchmark is the failure this skill exists to prevent.

### Boundaries - hand off, don't absorb

- Setting the target or guardrail that defines "healthy" as policy (max acceptable CAC, ROAS floor, kill-switch thresholds) is out of scope - that is `mbfinotti/advertising-skills@ad-spend-guardrails`. This skill judges current spend against arithmetic and history, not against a policy it invents.
- Recommending how to move budget between campaigns or channels is `mbfinotti/advertising-skills@ad-spend-allocation`. A verdict is not a reallocation plan.
- Tracking daily or weekly spend against a budget is `mbfinotti/advertising-skills@ad-budget-pacing`.
- Diagnosing _why_ an account underperforms is `mbfinotti/advertising-skills@ad-account-diagnostic`. Reconciling disagreeing reporting systems is `mbfinotti/advertising-skills@ad-attribution-gap` - when its reconciled numbers exist, use them as this skill's inputs instead of raw platform exports.

### Before starting - the intake

Ask these up front, batched. This is a tactical run on real numbers, not a strategy interview.

1. B2B, B2C/ecommerce, or blended? A blended business runs as two separate checks.
2. What evaluation window - and does it cover the conversion lag? (B2B: 4-6 weeks minimum, longer than the sales cycle for cohort reads.)
3. Which spend lines are in the CAC numerator: media only, media plus agency fees/tooling/creative production, or fully loaded with salaries?
4. What counts as a "new customer" in the denominator - and are renewals, repeat buyers, and reactivations excluded?
5. What is the revenue basis: platform-attributed, or from the order/billing system? Gross, or net of refunds and cancellations?
6. What is the contribution margin (or gross margin plus variable costs) per order or customer? Without it, break-even cannot be computed and the verdict may have to be withheld.
7. Are 4-8 prior periods of the same metric, on the same definition, available?

Then three scoping questions, because Step 1's metrics differ by orders of magnitude in effort and in how long their payoff lasts - that ordering cannot be picked for the user:

8. By when must the verdict land - a date, not "soon"?
9. A one-off read, or a standing check that will be repeated every period?
10. What is the effort ceiling: hours available, and whether finance or data can be pulled in at all?

Re-rank Step 1's menus against the answers, and say out loud which answer moved which metric:

- A hard near-term date keeps the run on the near-zero-effort variants (blended CAC, blended ROAS, MER) and deletes fully-loaded CAC, marginal CAC and any margin rebuild from this run - a narrower verdict, on time. Say which variants you deleted and why. A variant left ranked last reappears halfway through as a week of work nobody scheduled.
- A standing check promotes the slow ones: contribution margin, a consistent-definition history, and cohort grouping each cost a week once and near-zero every period after.
- Finance data that cannot produce a variant deletes it outright rather than demoting it: no salary-allocation rule means no fully-loaded CAC, and no contribution margin means no rung 1 either. Name both deletions at intake, and say then that the verdict will be withheld - never at the end of the run.

If you can read the user's exports (CSV, spreadsheet, warehouse extract), work from those. Otherwise ask for the totals per period. Record every answer in the report's definitions section - CAC is not a GAAP or IFRS term, no standards body defines what enters the numerator, so the definition agreed here is the only definition that exists.

### Step 1 - Establish the metric variant

"CAC" and "ROAS" each name a family of metrics, not one metric. Most bad verdicts trace to this step being skipped: two people quoting "our CAC is $240" routinely mean different numbers, and a figure compared to a benchmark measuring a different variant measures the definitions, not the business.

Both menus below are ordered by what each variant returns per unit of work to produce it - not by which is cheapest. Compute in that order and stop once the verdict is settled.

| CAC variant      | Formula                                                       | Decision it serves                       | What it costs to produce                                                            |
| ---------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| Blended CAC      | total marketing spend ÷ all new customers (organic included)  | whole-engine economics; feeds break-even | near-zero - both totals are already reported                                        |
| New-customer CAC | any variant with renewals and reactivations excluded          | subscription and repeat-purchase         | an hour where billing already flags customer status; a week where it doesn't        |
| Paid CAC         | paid media spend ÷ paid-attributed new customers              | channel efficiency                       | an hour to split the attribution - and worth no more than that attribution is worth |
| Fully-loaded CAC | S&M incl. salaries, tooling, agency, creative ÷ new customers | finance, boards, investors               | a week: finance's ledger, a salary-allocation rule, and agreement on what counts    |
| Marginal CAC     | cost of the next increment of spend                           | scaling decisions, not health            | a quarter, and deliberate test spend that cannot be recovered                       |

- efficiency: blended > new-customer > paid > fully-loaded > marginal
- value (for a health verdict): blended == new-customer > fully-loaded > paid > marginal
- effort: marginal > fully-loaded > paid > new-customer == blended
- compliance cost: fully-loaded > every other variant == none - once it reaches a board deck or an investor update it is a reported figure finance has to own, and redefining it later is a restatement, not an edit.

Marginal CAC's own decision rule (Demand Curve): a rising CAC is not automatically a problem to fix - check contribution margin first, and only test a new channel once the current channel's marginal CAC exceeds what the next channel could realistically deliver. Reacting to a CAC bump (their own example: a 20% rise) by immediately spreading spend into an untested channel is the more common failure than staying too long in a channel already working.

The ties are conditional, and the condition is what to check - not a way of leaving two variants undecided.

- **Value tie (blended == new-customer):** holds only where the business has no renewals, repeat purchases, or reactivations to miscount. The moment it has any, new-customer CAC sits strictly above blended, because it is the same read with a denominator error removed.
- **Effort tie (new-customer == blended):** holds only where billing already flags customer status, which makes both of them totals you already hold. Where it does not, new-customer costs a week and drops below paid on the effort line.
- **Compliance-cost tie (every variant == none, except fully-loaded):** every variant but fully-loaded ties at literally zero, because none of them ever leaves the marketing team's own report.

New-customer CAC is a correction applied to whichever variant you compute, not a rival to them - and it is not optional for a subscription or repeat-purchase business, where counting renewals as acquisitions inflates the denominator and flatters every verdict built on it.

**What this order starves:** fully-loaded CAC, and cohort CAC with it. Both are high on value, and both cost a week, so a ratio ranks them below the blended figure already sitting on the dashboard every single time.

- **Fully-loaded CAC** is the only variant finance and a board will recognise. Promote it whenever the verdict is going anywhere near a board deck, an investor update, or a fundraise.
- **Cohort CAC** is the only honest read of a lagging B2B business. Promote it whenever the sales cycle is longer than the window - Step 4's evidence gate withholds the verdict without it anyway.

Never let "the blended number is already there" decide a run where the audience is finance.

- Blended is always lower than paid when organic acquisition exists.
- Fully-loaded is always higher than media-only.

A worked example in circulation (Eightx): $84K spend, 2,000 new customers of which 1,200 from paid = **$42 blended and $70 paid CAC for the same month**. Silently switching variants makes CAC "improve" with nothing changing.

| ROAS family                     | Formula                                           | What it costs to produce                                                                                                                 | Caveat                                                             |
| ------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------ |
| Blended ROAS                    | total revenue ÷ total paid spend                  | near-zero - two totals the business already has                                                                                          | hides per-channel and per-SKU variance                             |
| MER                             | total revenue ÷ total _marketing_ spend           | an hour the first time, to assemble agency, tooling and creative into the denominator                                                    | denominator is the only difference from blended ROAS               |
| Contribution-margin ROAS / POAS | contribution margin (or gross profit) ÷ spend     | a week the first time - COGS, shipping, payment fees, fulfillment, agreed with finance - then a standing job to keep those costs current | closest to actual profit per ad dollar                             |
| Platform-reported ROAS          | platform-attributed value ÷ that platform's spend | near-zero - it is already on the dashboard                                                                                               | claimed revenue, not caused revenue; non-additive across platforms |

- efficiency: blended == MER > POAS > platform-reported
- value: POAS > blended == MER > platform-reported
- effort: POAS > MER > blended == platform-reported

- **Efficiency/value tie (blended == MER):** they are one metric with two denominators, and the tie holds only while agency, tooling and creative spend are small next to media. Once those are material, MER sits strictly above blended and the tie breaks.
- **Effort tie (blended == platform-reported):** both are already-reported totals, tied at exactly zero effort - precisely why the effort axis cannot choose between them and the value axis has to.

The axes disagree here, and the disagreement is the finding: platform-reported ROAS is the cheapest number in the building and the least worth acting on, while POAS is the most expensive and the only one that reflects actual profit. Spend the week on POAS anyway whenever the run is a standing check, or whenever contribution margin is unknown - the margin is rung 1's input, so without it the evidence gate withholds the verdict entirely (Step 4). That week buys the verdict itself, not a nicer number.

**Every ordering in this skill is a default, not a law.** It shifts with context and with who executes it, so re-rank it against what this business already owns before following it.

- A warehouse already joining ad spend to orders drops POAS to near-zero effort and puts it first.
- A finance team already publishing fully-loaded S&M each period does the same for fully-loaded CAC.
- An existing CRM cohort model does it for cohort CAC.

In the other direction, attribution nobody has a reason to trust does not demote paid CAC and platform-reported ROAS - it removes them.

Treat platform-reported ROAS as reported, never causal. Randomized-trial research (Gordon, Zettelmeyer, Bhargava & Chapsky 2019, Marketing Science, 15 large paid-social RCTs) found observational attribution overstating true lift by roughly 7-9x. Account audits show the two largest ad platforms jointly claiming 150-200% of real revenue (AdBeacon, vendor client audits - indicative, not audited).

As practitioner Ralph Burns puts it (Perpetual Traffic ep. 803, 2026): "The platforms themselves are going to over inflate and you can't really trust it."

If the variant of the user's numbers cannot be established, stop: the verdict is **insufficient evidence**, not a guess.

### Step 2 - Compute the metric set

Show each formula next to its result. Label every figure with variant, window, and source.

- `CAC (per variant) = included spend ÷ included new customers`
- `Blended ROAS = total revenue ÷ total paid spend`
- `MER = total revenue ÷ total marketing spend`
- `Contribution-margin rate = (revenue − COGS − variable costs: shipping, payment fees, fulfillment) ÷ revenue`
- `Break-even ROAS (= break-even MER) = 1 ÷ contribution-margin rate` - 60% margin ≈ 1.67x, 40% → 2.5x, 25% → exactly 4.0x. The same 4x ROAS is $1.40 profit per ad dollar at 60% margin and $0.00 at 25%.
- `Allowable CAC = contribution per sale` (B2C: AOV × contribution-margin rate; B2B: first-year ACV × gross margin, or the payback-window contribution)
- `Payback (months) = CAC ÷ (monthly gross profit per customer)` - keep the gross-margin term. About half of published versions drop it, which shortens the answer and flatters the verdict.
- `Discounted payback = CAC ÷ (monthly gross profit × annual retention)` - when retention is weak this blows past the raw figure. The gap is the early warning.

Three disciplines:

1. **Compute per plan, segment, and channel - never only blended.** The same $300 CAC is ~33 months of payback on a $9/month plan and 3 months at $99. One blended number describes neither.
2. **Mix-shift check before reading any blended trend.** Blended CAC or MER can move while every segment is flat, purely because the channel or segment mix moved.
3. **Missing data: renormalise the remaining channel weights, or withhold the blended figure entirely.**
   - efficiency: renormalise > withhold
   - Renormalising costs an hour and keeps a usable blend whenever the missing channel is small and its size is known.
   - Withholding costs nothing and is always defensible but returns no number, so it is the fallback, not the first move.
   - Never zero-fill a missing channel - a zero-filled channel silently corrupts every blend built on it.

### Step 3 - Build the comparison ladder

Three references, in strict priority order. Each rung is weaker than the one above it.

- efficiency: break-even > own history > external benchmark

One line covers every axis here, because cost runs exactly inverse to value: rung 1 is both the cheapest and the strongest, rung 3 both the most work to source properly and the weakest evidence. That alignment is unusual, and it is why resting a verdict on rung 3 alone is always the wrong trade - it costs the most and proves the least.

Excerpt. The rest of the file is on the canonical page and in the source repository.

## Cac Roas Benchmark FAQ

### Is Cac Roas Benchmark safe to install?

skills.sh reports 3 of 3 security scanners passed. Review the Security Audits panel on this page before installing in production.

## Machine access

- [Sitemap](https://skillselion.com/sitemap.xml)
- [llms.txt](https://skillselion.com/llms.txt)
- [llms-full.txt](https://skillselion.com/llms-full.txt)
- [Developer resources](https://skillselion.com/developers)
- [OpenAPI spec](https://skillselion.com/openapi.json)
- [MCP handshake](https://skillselion.com/.well-known/mcp)
- [API catalog](https://skillselion.com/.well-known/api-catalog)
- [AI catalog](https://skillselion.com/.well-known/ai-catalog.json)
- [Pricing](https://skillselion.com/pricing.md)
- [Auth](https://skillselion.com/auth.md)
- [AGENTS.md](https://skillselion.com/AGENTS.md)
- [Contact](https://skillselion.com/contact)
- [Home](https://skillselion.com/)
